I’m 73 and beginning RMDs with a $53,000 withdrawal. When will I’ve pay the taxes on this?

Dave 

Got a query about investing, the way it matches into your general monetary plan and what methods might help you take advantage of out of your cash? You can write to me at beth.pinsker@marketwatch.com. Please put Fix My Portfolio within the topic line.

Dear Dave, 

Welcome to the wild world of required minimal distributions. Happy birthday, and plenty of completely happy tax returns. 

For some individuals, it is a land of rainbows and unicorns, the place they fortunately spend the cash they saved whereas they have been working and do as they please. For others, it’s simply an unlimited tax headache and considerably of an intrusion to be pressured to withdraw cash it’s possible you’ll not want for residing bills, so as to lastly give the federal government its share after years of tax-free progress. 

I can’t precisely inform out of your letter which camp you might be in, however I’m getting a bit trace of frustration concerning the choices concerned and the way exhausting it’s to seek out the knowledge you want. 

There’s some good news for you, although, in that this one isn’t as exhausting to determine because it may appear at first look (nevertheless it’s not precisely simple both). 

Calculating your required quantity to withdraw

The simple half is that the quantity you might be required to withdraw is a knowable amount and gained’t change regardless of when or how you’re taking the RMD. It relies on the steadiness of your tax-deferred accounts as of Dec. 31 of the prior yr. So if that steadiness was $1.5 million on the finish of 2023, you’d apply the IRS formulation that’s related in your case, and give you some quantity near $55,000 that you need to withdraw, as you’ve gotten performed. Take it now, take it month-to-month, take it on the finish of the yr: There are pluses and minuses to every technique. The solely dangerous means is to overlook to take it altogether as a result of then it’s possible you’ll owe stiff penalties. 

Another potential plus: When you’re simply turning 73, your first RMD is just not due till April 1 of the next yr. So you may need extra time than you thought-about, however you may take it everytime you want. Most individuals want their retirement funds for residing bills and take out what they want once they want it, typically in extra of the required quantity, or they discover different methods to spend the cash like items to household or charity. 

The taxes due are a bit extra concerned, as a result of persons are sophisticated and each tax scenario is completely different. It’s simple to say one thing such as you’re within the 10% tax bracket, so including $55,000 of earnings would make your tax invoice on that quantity one thing like $5,500. It may find yourself both roughly. Your complete tax burden for the yr will rely in your different earnings, deductions and credit. Plus, you’ll have state taxes the place you reside. If that further earnings pushes you above sure limits, it’s possible you’ll find yourself paying extra tax in your Social Security, and it’s possible you’ll incur Medicare surcharges often called IRMAA. 

Your custodian can automate your tax withdrawals

But let’s get again to the straightforward stuff, as a result of you may automate this and simply not give it some thought ever once more. The custodian of your account ought to have the ability to take taxes out from any withdrawals and ship you a tax assertion on the finish of the yr – each to certify the RMD base quantity from the prior yr and to indicate the taxes withheld. 

“That may be one way to help yourself stay out of hot water,” says Nilay Gandhi, an authorized monetary planner and senior wealth adviser at Vanguard. 

If you find yourself paying an excessive amount of in a yr this fashion when all of it tallies up in your 1040, then you may settle that in your subsequent submitting and get a refund, identical to you’d in case you withheld an excessive amount of from a paycheck. 

If you select to deal with this by yourself, then sure, you’d owe estimated taxes all year long and also you’d have to remain on prime of that submitting course of. We all owe earnings tax all year long on the periodic or lump-sum earnings we get, whether or not it’s a paycheck, Social Security or tax-deferred withdrawals, we simply have a tendency not to consider it that means. We settle up by April of the next yr when our tax returns are due, and consider that as once we truly pay taxes. 

One of the explanations many monetary advisers steer their shoppers towards taking their RMDs on the finish of a calendar yr as a substitute of the start is due to this tax situation. You know extra about your general monetary scenario for the yr in November than you do in January. 

“Measure twice, cut once,” says Gandhi. 

You additionally get the good thing about tax-deferred progress on the quantity of the RMD all year long. You know on Jan. 1 that it’s important to take out $55,000, however that would probably earn $2,750 in curiosity at 5% by the tip of a yr. You nonetheless solely must take out that $55,000. That further progress continues to compound tax free, quite than you owing much more in taxes.