Asia Cup 2023: India’s quantity 8 determination – A spanner in well-oiled equipment?

When Shardul Thakur was picked forward of Mohammed Shami in India’s Asia Cup 2023 opener towards Pakistan, the choice might have raised eyebrows however was in keeping with the group administration’s penchant of late, looking for lower-order runs.  

Though the transfer didn’t repay on that event, with Thakur dismissed for a run-a-ball three whilst India was eyeing the 300-run mark, captain Rohit Sharma made it amply clear in the course of the World Cup squad announcement that it was a technique the group was going to stick with.  

ALSO READ: Asia Cup: The challenges of being KL Rahul

“It’s both the bowling depth and batting depth. We need to create that depth and that is something we found has been lacking in our squad for the last few years. We just wanted to make sure we got that batting depth somehow. When you talk about depth of batting, obviously the No. 8 and 9 positions become quite crucial.”  

“We saw in the first game in the Asia Cup here also where we fell a little short with the bat at the backend. It tells you how important that No. 8, 9, 10, 11 job is. Not just to come out and bowl the opposition out but also to contribute with the bat. It can make a huge difference,” he mentioned.

“We ended up getting 265. Another 10-15 runs, if we had played 50 overs, things could have been different. That is the winning and losing margin – 10 to 15 runs. We’ve spoken to the bowlers about how important their role is going to be, come the World Cup, and how they need to put their hand up to do the job for the team with the bat as well,” he added.  

Though on the outset it could appear that the bowlers have been short-changed, there may be additionally advantage to the argument that they might have introduced it upon themselves. During the 2019 World Cup, India most frequently did the job with simply 5 bowlers, whereas additionally having the luxurious of counting on Kedar Jadhav’s off-spin at instances. This meant that the administration had the wiggle room to area six specialist batters, excluding Hardik Pandya.  

But affected by a plethora of accidents and workload administration turning into the watchword of an more and more packed cricket schedule, India has most popular to use six bowlers in One-Day Internationals of late. The batters too haven’t stepped up persistently, making it seemingly inconceivable to have 4 specialist bowlers within the line-up.

A living proof is the truth that arguably the three greatest pacers within the nation – Jasprit Bumrah, Mohammed Shami and Mohammed Siraj – are but to characteristic in an ODI collectively. The sport towards Pakistan was yet one more pointer that this may increasingly stay a pipedream. 

FILE PHOTO: Shardul Thakur of India in the course of the 2nd Betway One Day International match between South Africa and India at Eurolux Boland Park on January 21, 2022 in Paarl, South Africa.
| Photo Credit:
Getty Images

While the rationale behind sacrificing a bowling choice for lower-order runs could seem acceptable, what evades logic is the administration’s method.  

Thakur has featured in an ODI eleven which incorporates Pandya and Ravindra Jadeja solely seven instances, has bowled simply 33.3 overs out of a potential 70 whereas finishing his full quota as soon as, and has batted 3 times for 20 runs.  

Similarly, Axar, who’s more likely to juggle the No. 8 spot with Thakur relying on circumstances, has performed with Pandya and Jadeja solely 3 times, scoring 32 runs and bowling 13 overs whereas by no means finishing his full complement of 10.  

Jadeja and Axar supply comparable skillsets with their left-arm spin, and the duo have solely featured in eight ODIs collectively for the reason that latter’s debut in 2014. Axar has batted simply 4 instances in these video games, scoring 33 runs at a mean of 8.25 and selecting eight wickets in 50 overs.  

Moreover, Thakur and Axar common lower than 19 with the bat, face lower than 13 balls per innings in ODIs and seldom full their full quota of overs. While Axar has bowled 10 overs in lower than half of the matches he has performed, Thakur has accomplished so in solely seven video games out of 40.  

At this level, the transfer to shore up the batting by comprising on the bowling entrance appears to be pushed extra by the concern of the unknown than by sure-footed decision-making.  

Sure, India’s batting has let the group down of late. Since November 2022, India has been dismissed for lower than 220 4 instances and has misplaced three of these video games. But then again, a case might be made for together with an extra pacer because the group has banked on the quicks to ship extra usually than spinners within the present World Cup cycle, even at residence.  

While the spinners have 64 scalps in 405.5 overs, the pacers have yielded 117 wickets in 584.4 overs for the reason that finish of the 2019 World Cup.  

In hoping to repair a troubled batting line-up by squeezing in a half-baked fail-safe determination, the group administration may find yourself throwing a spanner in what might be a well-oiled bowling equipment.